Sprained Ankle Won't Heal, but the Ligaments Are Fine? The Commonly Missed Anterior Process Calcaneus Fracture
Sprained Ankle Won't Heal, but the Ligaments Are Fine? The Commonly Missed Anterior Process Calcaneus Fracture
Article Summary
When an ankle sprain simply won't heal, the problem might not be with the ligaments. The pain location of an anterior process fracture of the calcaneus is similar to that of a typical sprain. On X-rays, it is easily obscured by overlapping bones, leading to missed diagnoses, and it is sometimes accompanied by Chopart joint injuries.
This article explains why it is easily overlooked, why walking feels unstable after a Chopart joint injury, and when it is necessary to schedule further MRI or CT examinations.
After a sprain, examination results may show no obvious issues with the medial or lateral ankle ligaments, yet pain persists when walking along with an unstable feeling when stepping down. Squatting might even cause discomfort in the knees and hips.
At this point, it is worth looking at an additional area toward the front of the ankle: an anterior process fracture of the calcaneus, as well as the often-overlooked Chopart joint injury. Anterior process fracture of the calcaneus is one of the most commonly missed foot and ankle fractures.

Figure 1: Sagittal ankle MRI image; the circled area indicates the location of the anterior process fracture of the calcaneus.
Why Are Anterior Process Fractures of the Calcaneus Easily Missed?
There are two main reasons: the location of the pain after injury is very close to that of a typical sprain; and foot bones overlap on X-rays, making small or non-displaced fractures difficult for physicians to identify.
The anterior process of the calcaneus is located at the front of the heel bone, near the anteroinferior aspect of the lateral malleolus.
A study involving 21 patients with injuries to the anterior process region of the calcaneus found that 60% of the injuries were clinically treated as standard ankle sprains. While this is the result of a specific small-scale study, it reminds us: persistent pain cannot simply be explained away as "a sprain that hasn't healed yet."

Figure 2: Sagittal ankle MRI image; the circled area indicates the location of the anterior process fracture of the calcaneus.
What Is the Chopart Joint? Why Does Stepping Down Feel Unstable After Injury?
The Chopart joint, also known as the transverse tarsal joint, consists of the talonavicular and calcaneocuboid joints, connecting the hindfoot to the midfoot. It allows the foot to both adapt to the ground and generate stable force.
During walking, the Chopart joint helps the foot accomplish two important tasks:
**During weight-bearing on ground contact:** Coordinates with foot movement to adapt to uneven and sloping surfaces.
**During push-off:** Coordinates with ligaments and muscles to provide stable support, allowing efficient transmission of force to the forefoot.
Therefore, when this area is injured, even if the medial and lateral ankle ligaments are intact, patients may still experience weight-bearing pain, weak push-off, or a feeling of instability. Studies have also observed that Chopart injuries may be accompanied by changes in gait kinematics, plantar pressure distribution, and hip movement; however, whether this directly causes subsequent knee and hip pain still requires individualized evaluation.
When Is an MRI Needed? What Information Can It Provide?
When symptoms persist but X-rays cannot explain the cause of the pain, an MRI can help evaluate:
Occult fractures and bone marrow edema: Identifies bone injuries that are not obvious on standard X-rays.
Midfoot ligament injuries: Including the bifurcate ligament (a Y-shaped ligament connecting the calcaneus to the navicular and cuboid bones), as well as stabilizing structures around the talonavicular and calcaneocuboid joints.
Concomitant injuries: Confirms whether the problem extends to another joint rather than being limited to just a small bone fragment.
The anterior process of the calcaneus is an important attachment site for the bifurcate ligament, and a fracture can sometimes be a diagnostic clue to concurrent injuries of adjacent joints and ligaments. In the aforementioned study, MRI revealed that 76% of patients had concurrent injuries in the calcaneocuboid and talonavicular joint regions, whereas the detection rate on standard X-rays was only 14%. This also underscores that examinations should not focus solely on the medial and lateral ligaments of the ankle.
An MRI is not necessary for every sprain. If precise evaluation of fragment displacement, articular step-off, and bony healing is needed, CT is equally important; both have distinct roles.
If an MRI has been performed and the results are normal yet the pain persists, that is another scenario. Please refer to "Why Does It Still Hurt When the MRI Is Normal? Four Sources of Pain That Imaging Can't See."
When an Ankle Sprain Just Won't Heal, What Should Be Re-evaluated?
First, verify whether the pain location falls outside the scope of the original examination.
Especially if the pain is concentrated anteroinferior to the lateral malleolus and discomfort persists during walking, push-off, or squatting, do not forget to include the anterior process of the calcaneus and the Chopart joint in the evaluation.
Considering an Evaluation?
People whose sprains have lingered for a while and whose test results show nothing wrong often think they can only wait for it to heal on its own. In fact, you can revisit and re-examine the exact location of the pain. When booking an evaluation, please bring your previous X-ray or MRI images and reports; the physician will start from there. Before your first visit to C-Medical Clinic, you may first read Preparation for Your First Visit.
Written by: Dr. Ping-Sheng Lu, Clinic Director
Last updated: 2026/11/14
Medical Disclaimer: This article provides general health education information. Individual diagnoses, examinations, and treatments must be evaluated by a physician according to actual conditions.
